Format: Stableford
Venue: [Radyr]
Score: 34pts (2nd)
Handicap mark: 3.8
Themes in reply: Unfamiliar greens; saving shots; opinions
Hi Colin,
Thanks for the response – read and absorbed! On Friday I played at Radyr with the Seniors, who were actually pretty good. It was a bit cold and cloudy with some wind. As you don’t know Radyr, I’ll give the pars of the holes as we go. We were of the front tees so it was pretty short but the greens were quite bumpy. We played a scratch Stableford – i.e. no shots.
1st – Par 4. Interesting! I had told myself that this was a 3 wood off the tee. We were playing in threes and the first of the group took a driver and knocked it over the green! The 2nd in the group hit driver and came up just short so I decided to change to a driver. I hit a good one and knocked it on the green but quite a way from the hole. 3 putts for a par and 2 points.
2nd – par 4. Hit a good drive virtually level with the green. A difficult pitch/chip as the green is quite small but I got it to about 12’. However, my first putt was too aggressive and I knocked it 4’ past and missed the one back – a 5 for 1 point
Dear John,
Thanks for the call. The St Andrews gig sounds wonderful.
As always, the start of the round is interesting to me. I’m glad you found the call beforehand helpful and you certainly started well, finding the green with your drive. For me, this is a highly significant shot, because you were with strangers, in slightly unfamiliar surroundings and with something to prove; yet you were able to find your timing immediately. This signifies to me that the method is beginning to become ingrained. The next step is to have it “ingrained” that you take the rhythm of a successful drive to the first putt.
However, even after a thumping first drive there is a problem with first putts on unfamiliar greens, which is that you don’t have any idea how hard to hit them. This lack of certainty is a distraction to your subconscious and likely to affect your timing; and timing a putt is the most difficult timing of all because the amount of force that needs to be delivered is so small and so precise, especially as compared to a full blooded drive on to a green. So, what’s the answer?
The answer is to pick up as many clues as you can about the speed of the green – how it looks, dryness/wetness, local opinion; absorb what you can about the speed and line of the putt i.e. slopiness; then fight against the natural urge to want a definite answer to the conscious question “how hard am I going to have to hit this?” This urge will have an element of embarrassment avoidance about it because you are in unfamiliar surroundings with unfamiliar people whom it would be quite nice to impress. It is a moment when you need to have confidence in your technique, and by that I mean the technique of virtually guaranteeing timing on every shot. I think this is an answer because I believe that a well timed putt fed by fully absorbed information about conditions will go close enough to at least satisfy embarrassment avoidance needs.
Having found your timing with a drive on to the green you are well placed to hone in on the rhythm of that drive fully confident that a similar rhythm will guarantee the putt being timed. The trick is simply confidence in the technique of producing a timed putt: your subconscious will do the rest.
If you have duffed your way to the first green then the answer is similar except that you will have to concentrate on consciously evoking a timed putt from the recent past in the hope that it will be a strong enough memory to switch on your timing. In any event, the trick is the same: confidence in the idea that timing is the be-all-and-end-all.
The evidence of your driving and pitching suggests that your timing was sweet right from the start and that you were able to take the rhythm from a drive to a pitch/chip. However your experience on the first two greens suggests that you were not quite able to take the rhythm on to the greens. The result was that your experience of putting on the first green, which stemmed from that very first putt, influenced your putting on the second green. If your experience on the first green had been just a little happier (and, as you can see from the preceding paragraph, I believe it could have been) then your experience on the second green would have been more satisfactory, and you might have saved a shot. This is a perfect illustration of the need to stick intensely to the method from the very first shot through to the last: they all count the same at the end of the round.
Using the word “aggressive” to describe that first putt on the second hole gives me a clue that you were short with your first putt on the first green and then found it very difficult to avoid forming the conscious opinion that because the greens were “slow” then you were going to have to hit the putts “hard”.
I think there is a subtle point here worth going over again. Your job is to give your subconscious the information it needs, and then to allow it to find the solutions using the mechanism “timing”. The permanent and pervasive threat to the process is that your conscious will take over the task of finding the solution. (My method distracts the conscious by giving it the job of feeding the subconscious. This only works as well as it does because I have identified the physical mechanism the subconscious exploits when it is given the task of exerting a specific force: double-pendulumic motion. It is possible to have some success by simply distracting the conscious with more or less anything – Timothy Gallwey’s “Inner Game of Tennis”. But success is more likely if you are able to distract the conscious with something that enhances the subconscious process.)
The ever present risk of your conscious taking over the process is well illustrated by the example of needing to notice that the greens are “slow” and then NOT deciding that you need to hit the putts “hard”. Both these terms are powerful, and have a sense of exactness in one’s imagination because they are derived from a combination of intelligent analysis and the memory of having played on lots of courses with “slow” greens, which required putts to be hit “hard”.
In reality, though, the terms “slow” and “hard” are understood by our conscious as relative terms. In other words, we can tell when greens are “slower” than what we are used to, and that that means that we are going to have to hit putts harder than usual. What we cannot quantify consciously in any precise way is just how much slower and how much harder. But, once we have noticed that the greens are “slow”, and we have had that observation confirmed by the humiliation of a putt left embarrassingly short, the temptation to consciously make sure that the next putt is hit “hard” can be overwhelming.
So, how, having noticed that the greens are “slow”, do you avoid turning that useful and necessary observation into a conscious commitment to make sure that the putts are hit “hard”, especially if you have just left a putt embarrassingly short? The answer is the same as ever: simply recognise and acknowledge the danger. For example, in your round at Radyr: despite spotting that the greens are likely to be slow you leave your first putt short. At that point, simply make a note of what the putting stroke felt like. This will distract your conscious by giving it the important the task of measuring the relative slowness of the greens using the feel of the putting stroke and the shortness of the resulting putt. By the time you are on the second green, you will have played a few more shots and have a stronger, fresher memory of a lovely pendulumic swing. As you face your first putt on the second green, your visualisation can be augmented by the experience of “measuring” the slowness of the first green. Then you evoke the last lovely swing and bingo! in it pops. Phew!
3rd – Par 3. It was about 145 yards to the pin but straight down the wind. Hit a 9 iron just left but pin high. Chipped to 4’ and missed – 1 point.
4th – Par 4 down the wind – Hit a really good drive and a 90 yard wedge to about 6’ – 2 putts for 2 points
5th – difficult Par 4 into the wind. Not the best drive but followed it with an excellent 6 wood that just went over the back of the green. Really difficult chip over a small bank, downhill to the flag and with the wind but I hit a beauty to 1’. Par 4 and 2 points
6th Par 4 downwind. Really good long drive only 80yds to the pin. Hit a lovely shot just short and it rolled up passed the hole about 6’. Holed a really good swinging putt for a birdie 3 and 3 points.
7th – Par 3 wind from the right. Just started the 6 iron too straight and missed the green on the left but pin high. Hit a lovely chip back to 2’. I knew the putt was coming from the right but it went completely and missed on the left. Bogey 4 and 1 point.
8th – Par 5 into the wind but the tee was quite forward. Hit a good drive and followed it with an excellent 6 wood to the green (there is a brook in front of the green). Putted down the hill about 3’ passed and this time the putt went straight instead of coming in as it should.
9th – difficult Par 4. I think I took the 2 missed putts to the tee. I wanted to hit a long draw but duck hooked it. Luckily I found it just short of the trees so I played a 9 iron out which ended up about 90 yards short of the green on a downslope. I then hit an excellent shot which checked up to 1’ from the hole. Made the putt!
16 points going out so played to my handicap. Could easily have been 20 points.
10th – Par 3 up the hill. 7 iron right on line, another 2 yards and it would have been really close but it caught a little bank and kicked off to the left off the green. Chipped up short and 2 putts for 1 point.
11th – Par 4 – good drive again leaving about 90 yds to the pin. Hit it to 6/7’ and 2 putts for 2 points.
12th – Par 3, green shaped like the letter C with the pin at the back. Good 8 iron to 6’ just missed so 2 points.
13th – Par 4 (this was always a Par 5 and it wasn’t until we marked the scores on the cards that we realized it was now a par 4!) Drive slightly right so blocked out with the 2nd shot. Wedged to left of fairway and then again to front right of green. A good long putt dead so a 5 and 1 point
14th – Short Par 3 over water. Wedge to 8’ and fast downhill putt dead so 2 points.
15th – Par 4 into the wind. V. good drive followed by 9 iron just short of the green. Excellent approach putt that I thought was in all the way only for it to dive right at the end and finish an inch away – 2 points.
16th – Par 4. The tee was forward a lot and I should have taken more off the dogleg. A good drive but it finished in some trees on the RHS. Had to chip it out and then chipped to the green a bit short and 2 putts for 1 point.
17th – Par 4 into the wind. The 2nd shot here is played over a road and fence. As the tees were forward I thought a driver would be too much. However, a 3 wood wouldn’t go far enough so I played a gentle driver. I didn’t commit and hit a poor drive short and right. Afterwards I realized I could have hit it properly. Anyway, had to hit the 6 wood with no hope of reaching the green. Wedged to about 8’ and missed for 1 point.
18th – Par 4 with a big valley before the green. Hit a good drive which went half way down the valley. Only 80 yards to go off a downhill lie and a good lob wedge to about 8’. 2 putts and 2 points.
So, 14 points coming back, making a total of 30. (34 if you count my handicap)
Conditions weren’t easy and it transpired that I came 2nd. The winner had 32pts and he is off 2. So I think I did myself a bit of good. It was quite interesting to play with the older guys. They don’t swing it fast but they do still hit it a long way. Their rhythm is good and they are good chippers and putters. I think their rhythm rubbed off on me as I swung it well and hit lots of good shots. My putting wasn’t great. The 2nd hole where my first putt went 4’ past put me off a bit. I really only holed one good putt which was on the 6th. I 3 putted 3 times and missed 2 short ones. If I can get rid of that I would be at least 3 shots better. I’m going to spend 30 minutes on the practice putting green before going out tomorrow.
Thanks for your help. It was a great help to talk to you before I played on Thursday. I’ll let you know how this weekend goes.
Regards,
John
3rd – I think that if you had timed the first putt on the first green, you would have 2-putted the second and sunk this 4-footer, saving three shots on the first three holes. It is interesting to me that your putting is your “weak” point, inasmuch as it is the thing that shows up when you are under pressure from the situation. By contrast, when you are under pressure within a game, i.e. in matchplay, it is often your putting that holds up. I think you have formed loads of opinions about putting in general and your own putting ability in particular, and you are finding it difficult to let go of them, and so under the right conditions they surface. I am quite confident that as soon as you commit to the idea that every shot on a golf course is exactly the same process, then your irrational nervousness about your putting ability will be a thing of the past.
4th – Another putt too many – that’s four so far.
5th – Fantastic.
6th – Ditto.
7th and 8th – These putts can be put down to unfamiliarity. You are swinging well now and it is likely that you timed the putts. The fact that they didn’t go in is wholly down to the difficulty of putting little balls into little holes on grass.
9th – Absolutely brilliant. Your commentary makes it sound as if you were annoyed with yourself for not simply looking for the rhythm and then accepting the outcome. It’s likely that you then intensified your search for the memory of the rhythm and rescued the hole with some great golf.
10th, 11th and 12th – Excellent par golf.
13th, 14th and 15th – Brilliant putting. (God, I love getting into this stuff. There must be something wrong with me – I’m living every shot!)
16th – Good recovery. You took responsibility for the decision on the drive, didn’t sulk, played proper golf and took the dropped shot. Well done.
17th – You do your own excellent analysis on this one. I don’t need to tell you the effect on the subconscious of words like “gentle”.
18th – Brilliant.
Loads of completely different shots executed successfully one after the other. This is proper golf – manoeuvring the ball with the same easy rhythm from tee to hole, from tee to hole. Your comments about the rhythm of your playing partners’ swings are interesting. Your tendency will always to be a bit fast at the top of the backswing, as it is with the vast majority of golfers. It may be that when you are playing with your normal playing partners, their swing-rhythms are the type to encourage you to be a little fast at the top. It might be worth finding a professional on the circuit whose rhythm you really admire (Fred Couples, for instance) and have some way of being able to watch him swing before you go out.
Regards,
Colin